chr 500-0bCHR Dark Textchr 500-0bchr 500-0b
  • About
    • Centre for Humanities Research
    • DSI-NRF Flagship
    • Partnerships
    • Funders
    • Reports
    • Staff
  • Iyatsiba Lab
    • LoKO
    • Sound Working Group
    • Documentary film
  • New Archival Visions
  • Research Platforms
    • Aesthetics and Politics
      • Factory of the Arts
        • About the Factory of the Arts
        • Convening the Factory of the Arts
        • Artists in Residence
      • Research Projects
    • Becoming Technical of the Human
      • Laboratory of Kinetic Objects
      • Research Projects
    • Migrating Violence
      • Research Projects
        • Political Theory and Philosophy
        • Trans-formative Consitutionalism
  • Research Chairs
    • NRF SARChI Chair in Visual History and Theory
      • Postgraduate bursaries and postdoctoral fellowships in Visual History & Theory
      • Postgraduate Module In Visual History, 2023 (HIS 735/835)
    • Charlotte Maxeke-Mary Robinson Research Chair
    • UK-SA Bilateral Digital humanities chair in culture and technics
  • Fellowship Programme
    • Fellows
    • Winter School
    • Visiting Scholars
    • Seminar Programme
  • Publications & Archive
    • Publications & Creative Outputs
    • Galleries
    • Video
    • Film
    • Podcast
  • News
    • Workshops
    • Conferences
    • Lectures
    • Special Meetings
    • Colloquia
    • Seminars
    • Arts Events
  • Contact
✕ When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to go to the desired page. Touch device users, explore by touch or with swipe gestures.
            No results See all results

            Jacob Cloete Graduates with PhD in Political Studies

            Congratulations to Jacob Cloete who has received his PhD from the Department of Political Studies. Cloete’s research focus on the complexities in the conflict in North and South Kivu in the DRC titled “The Politics of Belonging and a Contest for Survival: Rethinking the Conflict in North and South Kivu in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.” He was supervised by Professor Suren Pillay from the CHR. Cloete’s research abstracts reads as follows:

            Bittersoet – A short documentary film by Jacob Cloete

            “The Democratic Republic of Congo has long been challenged by a number of complex and protracted conflicts. Stemming from an interest initiated by his experience of being in the Congo as part of the South African contingent of a United Nations peace-keeping mission, Jacob Cloete’s thesis offers an innovative rethinking of the conflict in the North and South Kivu provinces of the Congo. Exploring the making of postcolonial political subjects, Cloete’s timely thesis persuasively argues that the conflict should be understood not as singular, but multiple, not as national, but as regional, and most centrally, not only as resource-driven, but shaped by the reproduction of cultural identities as political identities. The latter, he argues, should be divided into two phases, a politics of becoming, and a politics of belonging. In the politics of becoming phase,  the thesis draws on Critical Theory to make sense of identity formation in a part of the world which experienced a particular form of colonial rule, one that tied indigeneity to territory. And the politics of belonging phase of the thesis illuminates how the question of who belongs was answered in the colonial period in a way that bears heavily on the present and the future of who can belong, as a citizen and a native. Drawing on the extensive historiography of the region, the thesis deftly weaves together an innovative range of sources, including archival materials, visual and diary narratives, policy documents,  social media, and ethnographic knowledge, to offer an importantly nuanced understanding of the making of political identity in the present.  Cloete demonstrates that the importance of the distinction of how those in the Kivu’s describe themselves, first as Banyarwanda, and later as Banjamulenge, brings to the fore the important political consequences for war and conflict in that change in self-description at the local and regional level, particular in relation to Burundi and Uganda. A significant finding of the thesis is how local identities in political conflicts are also shaped by new modes of making community among groups of people with significant diasporas, and how internet chat rooms, and other discursive spaces on social media platforms produce and reproduce narratives that become part of the lived reality of conflicts on the ground. The thesis convincingly concludes that addressing a political conflict requires not just an intervention which halts violence in the short term, but requires interventions which address the more challenging proposition of altering how partisan communities in a conflict narrate their pasts and their futures. In the absence of these interventions, conflicts are more likely to take on the character of cycles of violence, with each new cycle adding a layer of historical memories of injustice and justice to the ongoing tragedy.”

            In addition to completing his PhD Cloete also produced and directed a documentary film in 2018 called “Bittersoet” which focuses on rural life in a small town in South Africa. The short documentary film can be easily accessed on Jacob Cloete’s Youtube channel.

            Here is the director’s note, Jacob Cloete, on the film:

            I was interested in the power relations that present itself in the making of a documentary film. My investigation led me to three limitations regarding documentary film making. These three limitations are: (1) the selectiveness of the frame; (2) the subjective experience of the audience; and (3) the invisibility of the film maker. The question was whether I could resolve these three limitations?

            Regarding the selectiveness of the frame I decided to use a still frame as far as I could. In this sense I rather use the frame as a ‘stage’ for performance, rather than a way to document reality. This is because I believe people generally tend to perform the moment they see a camera. Some performances are quite obvious and others are less obvious. Pointing the camera in one direction and framing only one section of reality, gives the subject an opportunity to perform knowing where and when to perform. I like to believe this is a type of contract between you and the subject you are filming. This solves the problem of voyeurism, only when people are aware of the camera and the direction it is pointing. For me panning and moving the camera without people knowing or are aware of it creates unintentional voyeurism. Regarding the subjective experience of the audience I decided to rather engage the subjective nature of the audience rather than trying to frame a desired response from the audience. My hope is that my film will elicit many questions and a range of feelings. When this happens, I know I will have succeeded in engaging the subjective nature of the audience.  Finally, the power relations regarding the invisibility of the film maker I decided to be guided by the following question: Does the image of the human subject take dignity away or does it return dignity? Or differently put: Is this poverty porn? Did I portray the human subjects in the film as helpless in need of charity or did I show their spirit and what they capable of without any appeal to charity? My answers to these questions allowed me to make the film Bittersoet.

            However, it might seem as the film reproduces the power relations it tried to escape, or the film-maker tried to escape and in the process rendered the subjects powerless and produces a voyeuristically look at what the film-maker thinks best captures the human spirit or the life of a small rural community. I wanted the film to be less about me and more about the community in which I grew up. It was then I realised that this story was about me. It was about parts of me I would like to tell. The story of Oom Hendrick, Ricardo, the Rieldancers and Josef are all connected to me. It was what I recognised in myself. Their stories are my story and this film was the only way I could tell it. I realised I am telling their story and my story in a way that make sense to me. Therefore, to truly understand Bittersoet you have to understand how I grew up. The hardships and the abuse I experienced while growing up in this community. The music is a result of this hardship. In the music we find a reason for another day. It made life a little lighter, bearable. The music has the same repetition and rhythm as life in the Hardevled. The recent style of Rieldance music is faster than the ‘original’ Rieldance music, which is slower and matches the rhythm of the film. Therefore, Bittersoet is about a rhythm and a spirit I noticed in rural areas. This rhythm is deeply ingrained in the fibre and the psyche of the people. I am a product of it. I might be critique on the ‘voices’ of the people that are not coming through, but I would like to disagree. Gayatri Spivak asked whether the subaltern can speak? My answer, like hers, is: Yes, they can but who is listening? And if you are listening, do you understand what they are saying?

            Share
            6

            Related posts

            August 28, 2025

            Social Sciences Research Council Award Announcement: Ingrid Masondo and Tammy-Lee Lakay


            Read more
            August 25, 2025

            Tyranny, The Third Term


            Read more
            August 22, 2025

            Artists Forum: with Phokeng Setai


            Read more
            August 19, 2025

            ENGAGE/REFLECT/CREATE: The CHR-Encounters Documentary Series


            Read more

            Search

            ✕ When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to go to the desired page. Touch device users, explore by touch or with swipe gestures.

            Sign Up to our newsletter


            Stay up to date with the latest news and developments from the Centre for Humanities Research.




            Recent Media

            • ENGAGE/REFLECT/CREATE: The CHR-Encounters Documentary Series
              August 19, 2025
            • Holding a Thought – The puppetry of Ukwanda
              July 18, 2025
            • The Herds
              April 9, 2025
            Centre for Humanities Research

            7 days ago

            Centre for Humanities Research
            Please join us for the next Humanities in Session Seminar, 'Tyranny: The Third Term." Date: Thurs 28 August 2025 Time: 1:00pm – 3:00pmVenue: The CHR’s Iyatsiba Lab For more info link on Bio... ... See MoreSee Less

            Photo

            View on Facebook
            · Share

            Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

            Centre for Humanities Research

            7 days ago

            Centre for Humanities Research
            Our fourth announcement of the Artist Forum is themed: Exhibition as MethodDate: Thurs 28th Aug 2025Time: 11:00 am - 13:00pmVenue: The CHR's Iyatsiba Lab,66 Greatmore Street, Woodstock (enter via Regent St)For more info link on Bio... ... See MoreSee Less

            Photo

            View on Facebook
            · Share

            Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

            Centre for Humanities Research

            1 week ago

            Centre for Humanities Research
            The Centre for Humanities Research (UWC) and the Encounters South African International Documentary Film Festival cordially invite you to the opening session of ENGAGE/REFLECT/CREATE: The CHR-Encounters Documentary Series, a monthly screening programme which will run from now until December 2025.The newly formed Proof of Life Trio, featuring CHR post-doctoral fellow Reza Khota on guitar, Asher Gamedze on drums and Sean Sanby on bass, will be improvising live to Charlie Chaplin’s 1936 silent film MODERN TIMES.The trio “attempts to bring together the composed idea that is at the same time endlessly malleable. Taking the phrase as a springboard into the unknown, or perhaps shared collective archive of grooves and affects. The only certainty is that every performance will be unrepeatable. The ensemble is also an offshoot of a collaboration between Khota and Gamedze in Free Music, Free Palestine. The name of the ensemble reflects on the imperative to improvise and think in the moment, as an antithesis to the new forms of techno-fascism, mechanisation and assimilation of the sensorium into the neoliberal order.” For more info link on bio : ... See MoreSee Less

            Photo

            View on Facebook
            · Share

            Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

            Centre for Humanities Research

            1 week ago

            Centre for Humanities Research
            Dear colleagues, fellows and friends,Please join us for the next Humanities in Session Seminar, and the book launch of Research and Activism: Ruth First & Activist Research, on Wednesday 3 September at the Iyatsiba Lab. This session will be led by Saleem Badat (co-editor of Research and Activism) who will be in conversation with Michael Weeder. For more information: www.chrflagship.uwc.ac.za/research-and-activisim-ruth-first-activist-research/ ... See MoreSee Less

            Photo

            View on Facebook
            · Share

            Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

            Centre for Humanities Research

            2 weeks ago

            Centre for Humanities Research
            Dear all,On Thursday 21 August, Maurits van Bever Donker will be in conversation (in person and online) with the University of Stellenbosch's Department of English about his monograph, Texturing Difference: “Black Consciousness Philosophy "and the “Script of Man”. Texturing Difference (2024), is available through Polity Press in the series Critical South with a Preface by Yala Kisukidi. It is located at the intersection of postcolonial and critical theory, literature and philosophy. In it, he situates the nuanced intervention of the Black Consciousness Movement in South Africa within the international conjuncture of anti-colonial thought and decolonisation. He makes the argument that the Black Consciousness Movement, in addition to its urgent political focus, should also be read as a philosophical intervention on the problem of Man that haunts the idea of race. ... See MoreSee Less

            Photo

            View on Facebook
            · Share

            Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

            Research Platforms

            • NRF SARChI Chair in Visual History and Theory
            • Andrew W. Mellon Chair of Aesthetic Theory and Material Performance
            • Factory of the Arts
            • Laboratory of Kinetic Objects
            • Seminar Programme
            • Publications

            Recently Added

            • Social Sciences Research Council Award Announcement: Ingrid Masondo and Tammy-Lee Lakay
              August 28, 2025
            • Tyranny, The Third Term
              August 25, 2025
            • Artists Forum: with Phokeng Setai
              August 22, 2025
            ✕ When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to go to the desired page. Touch device users, explore by touch or with swipe gestures.

            SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER


            Stay up to date with the latest news and developments from the Centre for Humanities Research.



            © 2025 UWC | The Centre for Humanities Research. All Rights Reserved. Designed By Spotkolours Design
                      No results See all results